Markku Eskelinen
Gonzalo Frasca’s response
Secret agency is at issue in Frasca's response, which denies the application of Aristotle to the open-ended interactivity of gaming.
Michael Mateas responds in turn
Narrativists vs. ludologists, material vs. formal constraints: Michael Mateas replies by identifying actors' roles in each division.
J. Yellowlees Douglas responds
J. Yellowlees Douglas adds more titles to Eskelinen's catalog of limnal games.
Richard Schechner’s response (excerpt)
Richard Schechner remembers the real-life side of interaction.
Stuart Moulthrop’s response
Stuart Moulthrop complicates the idea of self-contained games.